HanuAncutei.com - ARTA de a conversa!

Bine ati venit ca musafir! ( Logare | Inregistrare )

> Dezbateri Filosofie

Acest subforum este destinat dezbaterilor filosofice. Pentru discutii religioase va initam sa vizitati subforumul Universul Credintei.

7 Pagini V  « < 2 3 4 5 6 > »   
Reply to this topicStart new topic
> O Lectie De La Bosimani
Helmuth
mesaj 5 Jul 2008, 12:09 PM
Mesaj #106


Vornic
****

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 346
Inscris: 8 November 06
Forumist Nr.: 8.912



QUOTE(marduk @ 12 Jun 2008, 05:39 PM) *
Sunt fericiti pana da o molima in ei sau in sursele de hrana, atunci sa-i vezi ce fericiti sunt.


In mod cert, peste bosimani si alte comunitati egalitariste nu va da boala secolului XXI, obezitatea. Intr-adevar, cercetatorii au reusit sa demonstreze ca obezitatea, laolalta cu alte dezechilibre de nutritie si hrana, prevaleaza in tarile "dezvoltate", caracterizate de inegalitati sociale si de venit.

In studiul lor "Wider income gaps, wider waistbands? An ecological study of obesity and income inequality", aparut in Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 2005; 59:670-674, patru specialisti in epidemiologie, sanatate publica si problema obezitatii, in speta Kate E Pickett, Shona Kelly, Eric Brunner, Tim Lobstein si Richard G Wilkinson, demonstreaza ca inegalitatile socio-economice cauzeaza in randul populatiei asa-numita "boala a secolului XXI", obezitatea.

Prezentare generala a studiului
QUOTE
"OBJECTIVES: To see if obesity, deaths from diabetes, and daily calorie intake are associated with income inequality among developed countries.
DESIGN: Ecological study of 21 developed countries.Countries: Countries were eligible for inclusion if they were among the top 50 countries with the highest gross national income per capita by purchasing power parity in 2002, had a population over 3 million, and had available data on income inequality and outcome measures.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Percentage of obese (body mass index >30) adult men and women, diabetes mortality rates, and calorie consumption per capita per day.
RESULTS: Adjusting for gross national per capita income, income inequality was positively correlated with the percentage of obese men (r = 0.48, p = 0.03), the percentage of obese women (r = 0.62, p = 0.003), diabetes mortality rates per 1 million people (r = 0.46, p = 0.04), and average calories per capita per day (r = 0.50, p = 0.02). Correlations were stronger if analyses were weighted for population size. The effect of income inequality on female obesity was independent of average calorie intake.
CONCLUSIONS: Obesity, diabetes mortality, and calorie consumption were associated with income inequality in developed countries. Increased nutritional problems may be a consequence of the psychosocial impact of living in a more hierarchical society."


Solutia pentru stoparea raspandirii acestui flagel nu poate fi decat una: punerea in practica a masurilor egalitariste de redistributie: "Public policies promoting greater equality and reducing the burden of low social status may make an important contribution to reducing and preventing obesity. Relative deprivation may influence the effectiveness of policies designed to promote good nutrition and physical activity."

Studiul integral poate fi citit la:
http://jech.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/59/8/670#R21


--------------------
munceste mai putin, traieste mai mult!
Fericire fara bani
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
abis
mesaj 6 Jul 2008, 02:17 PM
Mesaj #107


Cronicar
******

Grup: Moderator
Mesaje: 9.444
Inscris: 8 March 04
Din: Bucuresti
Forumist Nr.: 2.507



Un studiu mai recent da urmatorul clasament al fericirii:
1. Danemarca
2. Elvetia
3. Austria
4. Islanda
5. Bahamas
6. Finlanda
7. Suedia
8. Bhutan
9. Brunei
10. Canda

Deci in top ten sunt, cu o singura exceptie, tari bogate.

Acest topic a fost editat de abis: 6 Jul 2008, 02:18 PM


--------------------
Asa ca, daca toata lumea ar fi bolnava sau nebuna, iar numai doi sau trei ar ramane sanatosi sau cu mintea intreaga, acestia din urma ar ajunge sa fie socotiti bolnavi sau nebuni, iar nu ceilalti (Aristotel)

Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
jet li
mesaj 6 Jul 2008, 04:00 PM
Mesaj #108


Dregator
*****

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 931
Inscris: 31 January 04
Din: ae
Forumist Nr.: 2.045



QUOTE
We never rail at the storms, the furious winds, the biting frosts and snows. To do so intensifies human futility, so whatever comes we should adjust ourselves by more effort and energy if necessary, but without complaint. Bright days and dark days are both expressions of the Great Mystery, and the Indian reveled in being close the the Great Holiness."

-Chief Luther Standing Bear

QUOTE
When you arise in the morning, give thanks for the food and For the joy of living. If you see no reason for giving thanks, The fault lies only in yourself. Abuse no one and nothing, For abuse turns the wise ones to fools and robs the spirit of its vision. When it comes your time to die, be not like those whose hearts are filled with fear of death, so that when their time comes They weep and pray for a little more time to live their lives over again in a different way. Sing your death song and die like a hero going home."

Tecumseh - Shawnee-(1768-1813)


http://www.greatdreams.com/wisdom.htm

Intelegeti voi astea ? Noi civilizatia moderna am luat "inelul puterii" si tinem strans de el. Suntem o adunatura de "Gollumi" fiecare in pestera lui. In orasele noastre nu avem nici urma de comunitate, suntem tinuti laolalta de politie. Daca politia ar disparea pentru o saptamana ati vedea cate aveti in comun cu omul de pe strada vecina. Cam nimic. Traim laolalta dar suntem singuri
Mai exista inca societati care nu au luat acest "inel". Fie l-au respins, fie nu au avut sansa. Nu e usor sa il respingi.
Sper sa vina o zi cand o sa ne dam seama ce facem. Faptul ca distrugem natura e un lucru, dar apoi distrugem si spiritul uman.
http://www.highcountrypassage.com/cgi-bin/...1&storyID=8
QUOTE
One of the most wonderful things about the trip was that the Pandaw II stopped at several remote villages along the Irrawaddy. The arrival of the boat was an event for the local people since they are seldom visited; at each stop, villagers would line the banks waving and laughing happily. The captain had arranged to stop at one community the boat had never visited before, and the warmth and hospitality of our hosts was overwhelming. As we walked through the village everyone greeted us, and many people, but children especially, surrounded us and walked along with the group. Little girls darted out to pick flowers to give to the women. One girl took my left hand, and another took my right; other children took other hands, and soon we were a daisy chain spanning the width of the village. And the laughter! Everyone was laughing and smiling, which of course inspired us to do the same.

We spent a happy afternoon here. As the Pandaw pulled away from shore the entire village lined the banks to wave goodbye, crying "Mingalaba!" This Burmese word has no literal translation to English, but simultaneously means hello, goodbye, and we are blessed. Mingalaba. As the Pandaw followed a turn and our friends disappeared from sight, I could still hear them singing out their blessings, the word tintinnabulating in the air like bells.


http://www.leelau.net/chai/burma.htm
QUOTE
What I found was the most authentic, untouched and traditional country in all of SE Asia. Everyday I would smile when I'd see something that reminded me of Asia in the 70s and 80s when I was a kid growing up there. Burma today resembles the Malaysia of old moreso even than Malaysia of today. So, if you want to see and feel the way Asia used to be (pre-1990s economic boom), Burma is the place.


Acest topic a fost editat de jet li: 6 Jul 2008, 04:04 PM


--------------------
"When the last tree is cut down, the last fish eaten and the last stream poisoned, then you will realize that you cannot eat money." ~ Cree Indian proverb

"He must be cut off from the past. . . because it is necessary for him to believe that he is better off than his ancestors and that the average level of material comfort is constantly rising."
--George Orwell, 1984
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Promo Contextual
mesaj 6 Jul 2008, 04:00 PM
Mesaj #


ContextuALL









Go to the top of the page
 
Quote Post
bdl
mesaj 6 Jul 2008, 04:12 PM
Mesaj #109


Cel Mai Amuzant Forumist
******

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 4.547
Inscris: 15 March 03
Din: Wilmington, DE, USA
Forumist Nr.: 86



QUOTE(Helmuth @ 19 Jun 2008, 12:16 PM) *
Poate afecta, caci cu cat comunitatea se arata mai multumita de vanatul adus, cu atat respectivul vanator are tendinta sa se considere superior celorlalti si indinspensabil societatii. Bosimanii se feresc atat de mult de a ajunge intr-o asemenea situatie, incat prefera sa nu mai multumeasca deloc, din contra.
Am convins cativa, ce-i drept, din anturaj. Nu stiu cata lumea care a citit blogul ori interventiile mele de pe forumuri a fost sau nu convinsa. Oricum, asta e o chestiune cu totul secundara, eu o sa continui sa propag adevarul indiferent de cat de multi il vor accepta sau nu.

rofl.gif rofl.gif rofl.gif
Altu care detine adevarul.... rofl.gif rofl.gif rofl.gif


--------------------
user posted image
-
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Helmuth
mesaj 7 Jul 2008, 09:51 AM
Mesaj #110


Vornic
****

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 346
Inscris: 8 November 06
Forumist Nr.: 8.912



QUOTE(abis @ 6 Jul 2008, 03:17 PM) *
Un studiu mai recent da urmatorul clasament al fericirii:
1. Danemarca
2. Elvetia
3. Austria
4. Islanda
5. Bahamas
6. Finlanda
7. Suedia
8. Bhutan
9. Brunei
10. Canda

Deci in top ten sunt, cu o singura exceptie, tari bogate.


Un clasament si mai recent include Puerto Ruco si Columbia in top ten. E de remarcat insa ca, spre diferenta de studiul New Economics Foundation (cel cu Vanuatu pe primul loc), acesta (realizat de World Values Survey) ia in considerare doar raspunsurile oamenilor la intrebari precum „cat de fericit esti?”, nu si realitati precum nivelul de poluare produs de tara respectiva.

Trecand peste, Ronald Inglehart, coordonatorul de la WVS si cel care a realizat topul pe care il citezi, a explicat in nenumarate randuri ca ceea ce face ca aceste tari sa fie in top ten nu e bogatia economica, ci mai ales democratia si nivelul ridicat de toleranta.
Legat de raportul dezvoltare economica-bogatie/fericire, in 1997, Inglehart scria:

QUOTE
The transition from a society of scarcity to a society of security brings a dramatic increase in subjective well-being. But we find a threshold at which economic growth no longer seems to increase subjective well-being significantly. This may be linked with the fact that at this level, starvation is no longer a real concern for most people. Survival begins to be taken for granted. Significant numbers of Postmaterialists begin to emerge and for them, further economic gains no longer produce an increase in subjective well-being.


In 2007, el scrie:

QUOTE
Happiness and life satisfaction rise steeply as one moves from subsistence-level poverty to a modest level of economic security and then levels off. Among the richest societies, further increases in income are only weakly linked with higher levels of SWB. (...)

Quite apart from their level of economic development, some types of societies do a better job of maximizing their citizens’ SWB than others. All 13 of the Latin American countries for which there were data showed higher levels of SWB than their economic levels would predict.

http://www.psychologicalscience.org/journa...s/inglehart.pdf

Ce concluzie tragem de aici? Ca dezvoltarea economica e necesara doar pana in punctul in care scoate populatie din saraciei si ii asigura un trai fara grija zilei de maine. Dincolo de acest punct, fericirea populatiei trebuie asigurata prin democratizare, toleranta, relaxare, sport, socializare, culturalizare etc.


--------------------
munceste mai putin, traieste mai mult!
Fericire fara bani
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
abis
mesaj 7 Jul 2008, 10:15 AM
Mesaj #111


Cronicar
******

Grup: Moderator
Mesaje: 9.444
Inscris: 8 March 04
Din: Bucuresti
Forumist Nr.: 2.507



QUOTE(Helmuth @ 7 Jul 2008, 10:51 AM) *
ia in considerare doar raspunsurile oamenilor la intrebari precum „cat de fericit esti?”, nu si realitati precum nivelul de poluare produs de tara respectiva

Nu vad de ce ar fi relevant nivelul de poluare atunci cand cercetam fericirea.
QUOTE
eea ce face ca aceste tari sa fie in top ten nu e bogatia economica, ci mai ales democratia si nivelul ridicat de toleranta

Posibil. Insa in conditiile in care societatilor respective li s-ar impune o oranduire egalitarista, democratia si toleranta ar deveni istorie. Prin urmare, si fericirea.


--------------------
Asa ca, daca toata lumea ar fi bolnava sau nebuna, iar numai doi sau trei ar ramane sanatosi sau cu mintea intreaga, acestia din urma ar ajunge sa fie socotiti bolnavi sau nebuni, iar nu ceilalti (Aristotel)

Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Helmuth
mesaj 7 Jul 2008, 11:30 AM
Mesaj #112


Vornic
****

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 346
Inscris: 8 November 06
Forumist Nr.: 8.912



QUOTE(abis @ 7 Jul 2008, 11:15 AM) *
Nu vad de ce ar fi relevant nivelul de poluare atunci cand cercetam fericirea.


Daca o populatie isi obtine fericirea printr-o economie ce presupune poluarea mediului, inseamna ca acea fericire nu e de durata si peste 3-4 generatii e probabil ca urmasii lor, ce traiesc intr-un mediu viciat si lipsit de resurse, sa nu mai fie la fel de multumiti.

QUOTE
Posibil. Insa in conditiile in care societatilor respective li s-ar impune o oranduire egalitarista, democratia si toleranta ar deveni istorie. Prin urmare, si fericirea.


Esti intr-o adanca eroare. In realitate, numai egalitarismul poate garanta functionarea satisfacatoare a democratiei. Doar atunci cand fiecare vom avea aceeasi avere si aceeasi pozitie sociala, fiecare vot va conta la fel. In schimb, in sistemele ce tolereaza inegalitati, cand o minoritate detine averi incomensurabile, e clar ca aceasta poate influenta si santaja dupa bunul plac activitatea politicienilor, legiuitorilor etc. Mai mult, cand doar o parte, mica, din populatie detine mijloacele de productie, e de asteptat ca restul sa depinda de ei, sa fie fortati sa accepte la angajare conditii ce nu ii avantajeaza (deloc sau nu pe deplin), sa nu aiba un cuvant de spus in privinta activitatii desfasurate la locul de munca etc.

Dupa cum spune John Myles, prof. de sociologie la U. din Toronto:

QUOTE
Democracy, by definition, is egalitarian (“one person, one vote”): rights are attached to people, not to their property. Markets, by contrast, are driven by inequality (“one dollar, one vote”) and, by deinition, generate more inequalities. In the 19th century, it was widely believed that mass democracy would destroy markets: the “many” would simply use their political power to expropriate the wealth of the “few” and markets would collapse. That never happened. [...]
Times have changed, and as the inequality trends indicate, Canadians face new distributive challenges. This is no time to rest on the laurels of those who preceded us. The viability of our society requires efficient markets; but it also requires effective democracy."


La randul sau, Frank Cunningham, care preda stiinte politice la aceeasi U din Toronto, completeaza:

QUOTE
"Inequality is an enemy of democracy. Autocracy is harmful to public spirit, since people understand themselves to be politically impotent. When a democratic society contains significant inequalities, it begins to resemble an autocracy. If money can determine for whom one is able to vote and dictates limits on what representatives can do once elected, understandable cynicism results and, with it, the weakening of public commitment."


Pentru mult mai multe, vezi zici: Inegalitatile economice conteaza.

De altfel, conform unui sondaj marca Financial Times, publicat la 19 mai 2008, marea majoritate a cetatenilor (76%-85%) inclusiv din tari dezvoltate ca Germania, Spania, Italia, China considera ca in prezent inegalitatile economice in randul societatilor sunt exagerat de mari si ca trebuie sa-i taxam mai mult pe bogatasi.
Ostilitatea generala fata de inegalitati, impreuna cu tendintele de redistribuire prin intermediul taxarii progresive sunt semne ca un viraj pe plan mondial spre egalitarism devine o reala posibilitate si ca el este vointa maselor.


--------------------
munceste mai putin, traieste mai mult!
Fericire fara bani
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
abis
mesaj 7 Jul 2008, 12:21 PM
Mesaj #113


Cronicar
******

Grup: Moderator
Mesaje: 9.444
Inscris: 8 March 04
Din: Bucuresti
Forumist Nr.: 2.507



QUOTE(Helmuth @ 7 Jul 2008, 12:30 PM) *
Daca o populatie isi obtine fericirea printr-o economie ce presupune poluarea mediului, inseamna ca acea fericire nu e de durata si peste 3-4 generatii e probabil ca urmasii lor, ce traiesc intr-un mediu viciat si lipsit de resurse, sa nu mai fie la fel de multumiti.

Cand faci un sondaj verifici nivelul actual al fericirii. Daca introduci si viitorul in ecuatie toate clasamentele sunt inutile, pentru ca sunt prea multi factori pe care nu-i poti anticipa. Spre exemplu, daca cei care traiesc in societati egalitariste vor ramane in urma cu productivitatea muncii, cu nivelul de instruire scolara, cu cercetarea stiintifica ori cu stiu eu ce altceva, in viitor vor fi mai putin fericiti. Daca cei nemultumiti cu oranduirea egalitarista vor fi trimisi la vreun soi de canal Dunare-Marea Neagra, la taiat stuf in delta ori pur si simplu lichidati, iarasi ma indoiesc ca va spori fericirea. La fel, daca intr-o societate bogata ca cele din topul mentionat de mine anterior introduci brusc egalitarismul, luand de la bogati si dand la saraci, dupa ce vei face praf astfel bunurile agoniste de primii cei din urma vor ajunge din nou la sapa de lemn, insa de data asta nu vor mai avea ce sa mai imparta, si iarasi le va scade fericirea...

Nu ai cum prevedea toti factorii care intervin in evolutia fericirii viitoare, asadar sa nu speculam.
QUOTE
cand doar o parte, mica, din populatie detine mijloacele de productie, e de asteptat ca restul sa depinda de ei, sa fie fortati sa accepte la angajare conditii ce nu ii avantajeaza

Am mai vorbit despre asta. Pe de-o parte proprietar poate fi oricine - oricine isi deschide o mica afacere ori cumpara actiuni. Pe de alta parte, exista concurenta si intre angajatori, pentru salariatii performanti. Daca esti lenes ori incapabil ar fi nedrept sa primesti acelasi venit ca cineva care performeaza in domeniul respectiv.
QUOTE
un viraj pe plan mondial spre egalitarism devine o reala posibilitate si ca el este vointa maselor.

Sa-mi spui despre "vointa maselor" atunci cand partidele comuniste vor castiga alegerile in mod democratic, nu asa cum s-a intamplat dupa al doilea razboi mondial.


--------------------
Asa ca, daca toata lumea ar fi bolnava sau nebuna, iar numai doi sau trei ar ramane sanatosi sau cu mintea intreaga, acestia din urma ar ajunge sa fie socotiti bolnavi sau nebuni, iar nu ceilalti (Aristotel)

Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
jet li
mesaj 7 Jul 2008, 03:21 PM
Mesaj #114


Dregator
*****

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 931
Inscris: 31 January 04
Din: ae
Forumist Nr.: 2.045



Dar de o viata simpla in care sa nu comande nimeni asupra altuia ce ziceti ? Fiecare traieste cum vrea si ii lasa pe altii sa traiasca cum vor.
QUOTE
Trouble no one about their religion; respect others in their view, and Demand that they respect yours. Love your life, perfect your life, Beautify all things in your life. Seek to make your life long and Its purpose in the service of your people. Prepare a noble death song for the day when you go over the great divide. Always give a word or a sign of salute when meeting or passing a friend, Even a stranger, when in a lonely place. Show respect to all people and bow to none
When you arise in the morning, give thanks for the food and For the joy of living. If you see no reason for giving thanks, The fault lies only in yourself. Abuse no one and nothing, For abuse turns the wise ones to fools and robs the spirit of its vision. When it comes your time to die, be not like those whose hearts Are filled with fear of death, so that when their time comes They weep and pray for a little more time to live their lives over again In a different way. Sing your death song and die like a hero going home.

Tecumseh - Shawnee-(1768-1813)


Dar vai, atunci fiecare o sa faca ce il taie capul !
Asta asa e, dupa 2000 de ani de "progres" am ajuns in stadiul asta. Fiecare om de azi e un trib separat, cu cultura si ideile proprii. Poate are si cativa apropiati care ii seamana. Nu are legatura cu ceilalti , nu ii simte ca oameni dintre care face parte de aici toate crimele de azi care in societatile primitive nu exista.
Nu avem sanse sa rezolvam asta si sa revenim la o oranduire mai libera. Tot gunoiul produs prin "progres" ne-a indepartat unii de altii. Intr-adevar "lucrurile pe care le detii ajung sa te detina". Nu am nici o idee cum am putea trece peste problema asta.

In insulele Maldive pana in 1960 cand India a infiintat un post de politie acolo, bastinasii nici nu auzisera de conceptul de "a fura", era de neimaginat.
Triburile de indieni din America de Nord nu aveau sefi, aveau un consiliu al batranilor. Astia nu erau alesi, orice batran cu experienta putea fi in el. Apoi sfatul asta dadea sfaturi smile.gif Nu ordine, dar rareori se intampla ca razboinicii sa nu asculte de sfaturi. Si nu ii aresta nimeni pentru asta. Nimanui de acolo nu ii placea sa dea ordine altuia. Ce concept

In afara de Comunism si Capitalism, mai e ceva. Astea sunt sisteme economice. Oamenii au trait milioane de ani fara economie si au dus-o foarte bine. Erau si mai civilizati decat noi.
QUOTE
Karl Marx recognized that workers without a choice are workers in chains. But his idea of breaking chains was for us to depose the pharaohs and then build the pyramids for ourselves, as if building pyramids is something we just can't stop doing, we love it so much

QUOTE
Because revolution in our culture has always represented an attack on hierarchy, it has always meant upheaval--literally a heaving up from below. But upheaval has no role to play in moving beyond civilization. If the plane is in trouble, you don't shoot the pilot*, you grab a parachute and jump. To overthrow the hierarchy is pointless; we just want to leave it behind.

*or yell and wave signs and write songs about what a bad job the pilot is doing (i said that)

Daniel Quinn


Acest topic a fost editat de jet li: 7 Jul 2008, 03:28 PM


--------------------
"When the last tree is cut down, the last fish eaten and the last stream poisoned, then you will realize that you cannot eat money." ~ Cree Indian proverb

"He must be cut off from the past. . . because it is necessary for him to believe that he is better off than his ancestors and that the average level of material comfort is constantly rising."
--George Orwell, 1984
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Rovaniemi
mesaj 7 Jul 2008, 09:52 PM
Mesaj #115


Vataf
***

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 172
Inscris: 5 May 08
Forumist Nr.: 11.565



QUOTE(jet li @ 7 Jul 2008, 04:21 PM) *
Dar de o viata simpla in care sa nu comande nimeni asupra altuia ce ziceti ? Fiecare traieste cum vrea si ii lasa pe altii sa traiasca cum vor.


nu prea merge, din pacate

chiar si in societatile primitive ,si cu atit mai mult in epoca moderna, exista specializarea muncii, si asta inseamna o interdependenta mult mai mare decit s-ar putea crede

asa ca, degeaba spunea cineva intr-un post mai sus cum ca daca politia ar disparea , toata societatea s/ar duce de ripa, si ca sintem foarte s\inguri in comunitatri de sute de mii de indivizi. nu e chiar asa / interdependenta loveste, si loveste rau ...
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
jet li
mesaj 7 Jul 2008, 10:32 PM
Mesaj #116


Dregator
*****

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 931
Inscris: 31 January 04
Din: ae
Forumist Nr.: 2.045



QUOTE(Rovaniemi @ 7 Jul 2008, 11:52 PM) *
nu prea merge, din pacate

chiar si in societatile primitive ,si cu atit mai mult in epoca moderna, exista specializarea muncii, si asta inseamna o interdependenta mult mai mare decit s-ar putea crede

asa ca, degeaba spunea cineva intr-un post mai sus cum ca daca politia ar disparea , toata societatea s/ar duce de ripa, si ca sintem foarte s\inguri in comunitatri de sute de mii de indivizi. nu e chiar asa / interdependenta loveste, si loveste rau ...


Interdependenta ? Nu am zis ca "oamenii sa nu faca nimic impreuna !". Sau crezi ca oamenii fac ceva impreuna doar cand sunt fortati ? Intr-adevar in jurul nostru asta vedem. Cum crezi ca ridicau indienii corturile din piele de bizon, inalte de 3, 4 metri ? Probabil se rugau de vecini ? Sau ii plateau ? Sau ii fortau ? smile.gif
Ce metode barbare
Adevarul e ca erau o comunitate, ca un grup de prieteni si se ajutau intre ei. Fiecare asezare indiana numara cam 20 de familii si distanta obisnuita intre asezari era 1 km.

Triburile primitive functioneaza pentru ca fiecare individ lucreaza pentru trib in orice face, si e mandru de asta.
Nu il obliga nimeni.
Stiati ca in caz de razboi nu te obliga nimeni sa te duci ? Si nici nu erai considerat las ? Ziceau "asa e el", si atat. Nu am ajuns la nivelul asta azi. Apoi mergand spre batalie unii se intorceau acasa. Altii continuau. Pentru ca fiecare era in stare sa gandeasca pentru el, nu formau o turma.

Si in societatea noastra exista tendinta copiilor de a-si cauta un trib, de a face parte din ceva pentru care sa "lucreze" , sa simta ca are o importanta undeva. Ce ii oferim ? Bani. Nu un trib. Si astfel intentiile lui bune dispar ajunge lacom si nepasator. Si de fapt cui ii pasa de el ? E doar unul im plus la marea gramada care suntem - nu avem nici o unitate.

Sper ca intelegeti ca eu vorbesc aici despre viata oamenilor de atunci. Nu imi spuneti ce avantaje a adus tehnologia. Singurele valori, valabile si azi, si care se observa in cazul unui dezastru sunt prietenii si familia. Viata moderna le distruge.

Acest topic a fost editat de jet li: 7 Jul 2008, 10:36 PM


--------------------
"When the last tree is cut down, the last fish eaten and the last stream poisoned, then you will realize that you cannot eat money." ~ Cree Indian proverb

"He must be cut off from the past. . . because it is necessary for him to believe that he is better off than his ancestors and that the average level of material comfort is constantly rising."
--George Orwell, 1984
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
axel
mesaj 8 Jul 2008, 01:11 AM
Mesaj #117


Domnitor
******

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 6.207
Inscris: 3 October 03
Forumist Nr.: 899



QUOTE(jet li @ 7 Jul 2008, 11:32 PM) *
Interdependenta ? Nu am zis ca "oamenii sa nu faca nimic impreuna !". Sau crezi ca oamenii fac ceva impreuna doar cand sunt fortati ? Intr-adevar in jurul nostru asta vedem. Cum crezi ca ridicau indienii corturile din piele de bizon, inalte de 3, 4 metri ? Probabil se rugau de vecini ? Sau ii plateau ? Sau ii fortau ? smile.gif
Ce metode barbare

Indienii de care vorbesti erau in stare sa inalnte corturi din piele de bizon, iar societatea vestica actuala e in stare sa construiasca poduri de kilometrii si inalte de sute de metrii, sa construiasca cladiri de aproape un km, sa ajunga pe luna, etc, etc. Fiecare dupa posibilitati ohyeah.gif


--------------------
Azi avem.

Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Blakut
mesaj 9 Jul 2008, 12:35 AM
Mesaj #118


Domnitor
******

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 3.713
Inscris: 16 May 04
Din: Bucuresti, the belly of heck
Forumist Nr.: 3.508



QUOTE
Ce ii oferim ? Bani. Nu un trib. Si astfel intentiile lui bune dispar ajunge lacom si nepasator. Si de fapt cui ii pasa de el ? E doar unul im plus la marea gramada care suntem - nu avem nici o unitate.


Ei nu e nici un trib? Dar galeriile de fotbal, stilurile de viata care rezulta din stilurile muzicale? Moda? Astea nu sunt oare tot niste forme de a apartine unui trib?


--------------------
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
jet li
mesaj 9 Jul 2008, 10:38 AM
Mesaj #119


Dregator
*****

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 931
Inscris: 31 January 04
Din: ae
Forumist Nr.: 2.045



QUOTE(Blakut @ 9 Jul 2008, 02:35 AM) *
Ei nu e nici un trib? Dar galeriile de fotbal, stilurile de viata care rezulta din stilurile muzicale? Moda? Astea nu sunt oare tot niste forme de a apartine unui trib?

Ba da. E dorinta natural a oamenilor de a simti ca fac parte dintr-un grup. Dar totul dureaza cateva ore pe saptamana , un fel de "medicament" pentru suflet. Un trib adevarat trebuie sa dureze tot timpul. Ai vazut filmul Fight Club ? Cam asa e si cu triburile astea moderne


--------------------
"When the last tree is cut down, the last fish eaten and the last stream poisoned, then you will realize that you cannot eat money." ~ Cree Indian proverb

"He must be cut off from the past. . . because it is necessary for him to believe that he is better off than his ancestors and that the average level of material comfort is constantly rising."
--George Orwell, 1984
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
axel
mesaj 18 Jul 2008, 12:51 AM
Mesaj #120


Domnitor
******

Grup: Membri
Mesaje: 6.207
Inscris: 3 October 03
Forumist Nr.: 899



http://miniamericanflags.deviantart.com/ar...ialism-48578733 :



Socialism is a system that depends on all individuals agreeing to work towards the common good of its community. This system is only possible if everyone cooperates willingly. Unfortunately for you there are individuals, like me, who disagree to work towards the good of the community. I wish to work to further my own selfish desires.

There are only a couple of options for socialism to work. One is to form a small commune of individuals who agree with socialism, and all work towards the good of one another without interfering with the rest of society. The other option is to create a government system that forces individuals to comply with your philosophy.

Any system, such as this, would have to force every individual to work for the good of everyone else. It is your individual choice if you wish to live your life for others, this is a right that is only taken away by force.

Those of you who hold socialism as your own personal credo, you are not a concern. But those of you who use the government to force your ideals on others, listen well. We will not let you rob and steal without exposing your ideology for what it really is: slavery.


--------------------
Azi avem.

Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
jet li